Lawsuit Filed Against Babysitting Facility Where Toddler Was Abused

A civil lawsuit was recently filed against the operator of a babysitting facility in the Chicagoland after law enforcement officials determined that abuse from a caregiver caused the child’s death. The lawsuit claims that the operator of the babysitting facility was negligent in failing to provide proper supervision of staff and failing to provide timely medical care for the injured child.

After an exhaustive investigation by the medical examiners office, forensic evidence established that the 20-month-old girl was hit with great force several times by the caregiver on August 31, 2009.  Four days later, the child died from multiple injuries including: cranio cerebral injuries, blunt head trauma and child abuse.

Presently, the caregiver is in the custody of the Cook County Sheriff as he waits a trial date for his murder chargers.

Home-based care for children

Home-based day care is an increasingly popular care arrangement for children.  In Illinois, home-based day care facilities outnumber traditional daycare by a margin of nearly 4 to 1.  While the home-based environment may be different than a traditional day care center, home-based day care facilities still face substantial regulations from the Department of Children and Family Services.

State regulations specify almost all aspects of day care including:

  • Staffing
  • Training
  • Meal preparation and nutrition
  • Requirements for the particular home
  • Night care for children
  • Admission and discharge of children
  • Daily programs for children

State inspectors or representatives from a licensed state welfare agency-licensing agency make periodic inspections of the facilities to ensure compliance with the regulations.  If you wish to learn more about a particular day care facility in Illinois, you may call the Day Care Information Line, 1-877-746-0829.  Representatives can provide you information on the facilities past record of care including substantiated violations.

Related:

Mom sues babysitting facility in infant’s child abuse death, CBS Chicago June 7, 2011

Summary of Licensing Standards For Day Care Centers.pdf

Summary of Licensing Standards For Day Care Homes.pdf

Federal Government Issues New Crib Standards for Hotels; Daycare Centers


[Caption: A ban on “drop side” cribs may render scenarios like this one obsolete. (Photo courtesy of CPSC)]


In response to at least 32 infant deaths caused by “drop-side” cribs, the Consumer Product Safety Commission (CPSC) recently issued stringent new rules for cribs in hotels. As of December 2012, all U.S. hotels and motels must:

  • Remove all drop-side cribs
  • Use cribs with stronger wood, to prevent slat breakage
  • Strengthen mattress supports
  • Use anti-loosening devices to help keep hardware secure

The new regulations also affect childcare centers, and places “of public accommodation.” The rules come after a general ban of drop-side cribs on June 28.

“I’m pleased that parents, grandparents and caregivers can now shop with confidence,” said CPSC Chairman Inez Tenenbaum in a statement. “The day has come where only stronger and safer cribs are available for consumers to purchase.”

Drop-side cribs have a detachable wall that “slides” up and down, which creates numerous opportunities for infants to accidentally strangle or suffocate themselves. In the past, drop-side cribs have been popular with parents because they allow access to their infants at varying heights.

The CPSC recommends that parents perform an immediate safety check of cribs at home. The CPSC advises parents to:

  • Never place pillows, toys, and thick quilts in a baby’s sleep environment
  • Make sure there are no gaps larger than two fingers between the sides of the crib and the mattress
  • Stop using cribs that are more than ten years old
  • Never place cribs near windows with blinds, curtain cords, or baby monitor cords.

According to the CPSC, more than 11 million cribs and bassinets have been recalled since 2007.  

Related:

Crib Injuries Land Thousands of Toddlers in ER Each Year February 17, 2011, Business Week

CPSC Crib Information Center

Drop Sided Cribs: Will Saving Your Back Cost Your Child Their Life?

Child-Related Products Must Now Include Registration Cards To Alert Parents Of Safety Concerns

CPSC Announces New Mandatory Crib Standards June 28, 2011

Funding Pulled From Group Home For Children Following Discovery Of Abuse

lonely boyFor handicapped children, living in a group home environment with peers facing similar disabilities can be a real gift.  Unlike other living arrangements where children can feel significantly out of place, group homes for disabled children and young-adults hopefully foster an environment of support and encouragement.

Understandably, many of these young people require supervision.  When staff at these facilites fail to use their common sense and supervisory responsibility, the opportunity for dangerous and abusive conditions rears its head.  

Abusive conditions were recently discovered at a group home for young-adults in Florida. An investigation completed by in collaboration by officials from Florida's Department of Children & Families, Attorney General's office and local police confirmed that staff at a facility identified at O'Carroll Homes, tortured a 17-year-old girl who was a resident at the facility.

The investigation revealed that four employees burned the severely disabled teen with a clothes iron in January.  In addition to the trauma of the incident, the young woman sustained serious burns to her legs and ankles.  According to reports, two staff members at the facility actually abused the girl, while two other staff members watched the abuse without any intervention.

In addition to criminal charges brought against the individual staff members, offcials have also stripped the group homes Medicaide funding.  The decision to strip the faciliities public funding, will likely force the facility to close its doors as most group homes rely almost entirely on government funding to operate.

As a lawyer who has represented children injured and abused in a group home setting, I believe the owners of this facility are partially to blame for this incident.  The fact that multiple staff members where involved in this horrific incident leads me to believe that this facility truly has more than a 'bad seed'-- or two.  

Frequently, in the course of litigating abuse in institutional settings, I find that most abuse is perpetrated over a long period of time.  As owners of a facility caring for exceptionally vulnerable young adults, I would find it completely shameful if the owners were doing nothing more than reaping the profits from this important facility.

Child's Death At Day Care Demonstrates Need For Tighter Regulations

Tragedy has stunned a Chicagoland community after a two-year-old girl at a home-based day care drowned when she managed to gain access to a swimming pool at the home.  The child was one of 10 children (7 children from outside the home and 3 of her own) the caregiver was looking after at her home in Aurora, IL.

Just months ago, the Illinois Department of Children and Family Services (DCFS) conducted an allegation of neglect at the same operation, and while the neglect allegation was not substantiated--- the owner of the facility was cited for for operating an unlicensed day care facility.

DCFS officials have confirmed that the owner of the day care did apply for a license in June, but the application had not been reviewed and no license was granted at the time of this incident.

Licensing of Day Care Facilities

Most states have licensing regulations for all types of day care facilities.  In Illinois, home day care operators that care for four our more children must be licensed by the state in order to assure that there is sufficient staffing levels in place to properly look after the children.

Would more staffing have prevented this day care tragedy?  The reality is that this tragedy could have occurred under a variety of circumstances-- with any number of caregivers.  However, as a parent I know how demanding looking after two small children can be.  Ten-- I can't even imagine!  No doubt an extra set of eyes couldn't hurt!

While the investigation into this matter continues, I suggest that the state take a much harder line when it comes to the regulation of day care facilities to ensure the safety of all children.  Further regulation of all day care facilities would provide an added level of safety for children and piece of mind for parents. 

Related:

Aurora Day Care Where Toddler Died Had No License, CBSChciago.com

Preventing Institutional Child Abuse By Carefully Selecting A Facility

Understanding The Regulations Pertaining To Day Care Facilities Is Crucial To Protecting Your Child

Reporting Child Abuse: Not Just The Right Thing To Do-- But Also The Law

child abuseIn many situations, a child may be unable or unwilling to report their own abuse or neglect.  Therefore, it is important that the network of adults in a child’s life are vigilant advocates, giving abused children a voice.  A child may not report abuse because they cannot talk, do not understand what is happening, are afraid, or have no one to talk to. 

That is why there are mandated reporters, people and professions who have a legal requirement to report child abuse or neglect to the State.  Many times, these people are in the best position to recognize signs of possible abuse (325 ILCS 5/4; 720 ILCS 5/11-20.2). 

Mandated reporters of child abuse include:

  • Doctors
  • Nurses
  • Teachers
  • Social workers
  • Psychologists
  • Police officers
  • Members of the clergy
  • Child care personnel. 

If a mandated reporter fails to report suspected abuse, they can face disciplinary action (325 ILCS 5/4). 

These are not the only people who should report child abuse or neglect.  Anyone who even suspects child abuse or neglect should call the Child Abuse Hotline at (800) 25-ABUSE or 1-800-252-2873 or (217)524-2606 if calling from outside Illinois. 

In Illinois, about two-thirds of calls come from mandated reporters.  If a hot-line worker determines that the report qualifies as child abuse/neglect, it is reported to the Department of Children and Family Services (DCFS), where a social worker opens an investigation within 24 hours.  If the investigator determines that the report was made in good faith or the reported abuse did occur, a formal investigation is opened.  In 2008, Illinois had 111,890 reports of child abuse/neglect, and 30,047 indicated/confirmed cases.

During the investigation, the child can be placed in protective custody if the investigator determines that they are at imminent risk.  The investigator makes a decision on the case within 60 days (unfounded or confirmed).  In Illinois, over a quarter of all cases are confirmed.  DCFS must report the case to local law enforcement if it involves a serious allegation (death, sexual abuse, torture, internal injuries, and head injuries, among others. 

A person who is accused of child abuse/neglect (the perpetrator) can appeal of the indicated finding in the DCFS’ Administrative Hearing Unit.  The Administrative Law Judge (ALJ) makes a recommendation to the Director of DCFS, who then issues a final decision.  If the appeal is denied, the perpetrator can appeal in circuit court.    

Child Injuries v. Child Abuse

Children are active and adventurous and their activities can lead to accidental injuries.  Common accidental injuries include: broken bones from falls, choking, and sickness from ingesting toxic substances.  However, children can also suffer injuries from abuse and neglect.  Therefore, it is important to learn the signs of abuse so you can report it.

Child care facilities must take precautions to ensure that the physical property is free of hazards in order to prevent dangerous falls and accidents.  This includes proper radiator covers, no loose electrical cords, picking up toys and keeping the play area clean, wiping up spills, keeping walkways clear, storing cleaning products and toxic substances out of the reach of children.  Even a caregiver’s purse can pose a risk to young children, keys and makeup can be choking hazards, medicine can be lethal for a small child. 

Illness and disease is another factor to consider with child care settings.  Children do not appreciate or understand germs.  They chew on toys, put things in their mouths, and share toys.  Caretakers must ensure that children only play with toys suitable for their age group, inspect toys for deterioration or loose parts, and clean toys and surfaces regularly.  

Related Child Injury Law Blog Entries:

Toddler Receives Burns In Daycare Due To Caregiver's Poor Judgment

Foster Care System Failing To Protect Those Who Need It The Most

Despite The Recent Publicity, Children Continue To Remain Susceptible To Abuse From Clergy

Preventing Institutional Child Abuse By Carefully Selecting A Facility

daycare.jpgChildren, like the elderly, are a vulnerable group that requires oversight, protection, and regulations to protect them.  (See “Children in Day Care Are Susceptible to Many of the Same Problems Our Elderly Nursing Home Patients Encounter”)

Choosing a Child Care Provider

When choosing a child care facility, there are a number of factors to keep in mind.  It is important to find a high-quality facility, where you feel your children are receiving the best care and attention.  (Trust Your Instinct When Placing a Child in Daycare with Potential Hazards)

When you visit potential child care centers, you should look for:

  • A positive and safe environment
  • Good communication between the parents and staff
  • Long-term caregivers with experience or training in child development
  • A small caregiver to child ratio, to ensure that your child receives proper attention

The group, Child Care Aware, lists five recommendations when choosing a child care facility:

  1. Start early – Give yourself enough time to look at multiple child care facilities and properly weigh your options
  2. Call local child care resources and referral (CCR&R) agencies
  3. Ask questions when you visit a facility – look around, check for hazards, count the number of children/caregivers, and ask about training and background checks
  4. Make a decision
  5. Stay involved

Child care is expensive, so naturally, price will be one factor in your decision.  In two-parent households, 10.6% of the family income goes toward child care.  There are some state assisted child care programs funded by the Child Care and Development Fund (CCDF), and some families may be eligible for tax benefits (Earned Income Tax Credit (EITC), Child Tax Credit, and Child and Dependent Care Credit).

Child Care Options

The United States has more than 335,000 licensed child care facilities that offer supervised, regular care of children for a fee.  (Type and number of licensed child care facilities by state).  Child care options include:

  • Child Care Centers – Nonresidential facilities
  • Family Child Care/ Group Day Care Home/Day Care Home – Residential facilities
  • Family/Friend/Neighbor Care – Relative/friend/neighbor provides care in their own home or the child’s home
  • Nanny/Au Pair – One person cares for child in the child’s home, sometimes also living there

The Survey of Income and Program Participation (SIPP) has a table showing the distribution of child care arrangements for children younger than 15 years of age. 

Arrangement Type

Percentage Distribution

Relative Care

47.4

     Mother

4.3

     Father

17.2

     Grandparent

19.4

     Sibling or other relative

6.4

Organized Care Facility

23.8

     Day care center

18.1

     Nursery or preschool

5.0

     Head Start

0.8

Other Nonrelative Care

15.6

     In child’s home

3.6

     In provider’s home

12.0

     Family day care

7.4

     Other nonrelative

4.6

Other

13.2

     Other arrangement

2.5

     No regular arrangement

10.8

Total

100.00

Early education programs offer an alternative to child care.  The programs work on developing skills to prepare the children for school.  These programs include:

  • Early Head Start (EHS) – Federally funded program for low income families with young children (Head Start Locator)
  • Head Start – Same as EHS but for older children, 3-5 years old.
  • State-funded prekindergarten programs – For children 3-4 years of age

Federal Regulation

Individual states regulate and license child care.  Federal law does require that states regulate child care facilities to prevent infectious disease, require premise safety, and health and safety training.  As expected, regulations vary from state to state. 

Regulations generally include: licensing requirements, inspections, child to staff ratio, background checks, health and safety requirements, child development, and parent communication/involvement.  (State licensing requirements)

 

Age Groups

Developmental Stage

Age

Functional Definition

Infant

0-12 months

Birth to ambulation

Toddler

13-35 months

Ambulation to accomplishment of self-care routines such as use of the toilet

Pre-schooler

36-50 months

From achievement of self-care routine to entry into regular school

School-Age Child

5-12 years

Entry into regular school, including kindergarten through 6th grade

State Regulation - Illinois

The Department of Children and Family Services (DCFS) regulates Illinois licensing and standards (Illinois child care Rules).  There were 2,907 licensed day care facilities, 473 group day care homes, and 10,050 licensed day care homes in Illinois in 2007.  These facilities have the capacity to serve over 295,000 children.  (Illinois Daycare Listings)

Illinois regulations set forth minimum standards for child care facilities and institutions.  The Illinois Child Care Act (225 ILCS 10) has standards, licensing requirements, background checks, and responsibilities (Child Care Act Study Guide).  (See “Day Care Worker Leaves Children Unattended in Gym – Situation Demonstrates the Need for More Regulation of Child Care in Alternative Settings”)

The Illinois Administrative Code includes rules covering the licensing standards for child care facilities:

Signs Of Childhood Abuse May Not Always Be Apparent

stopabuse.jpgIt is not uncommon for children to have scrapes and bruises from learning to walk or playing games.  But, many common injuries can also be caused by abuse or neglect.  There is no one injury that makes it obvious that abuse is occurring.  Instead, it is often the regularity of injuries or location or grouping of injuries that are indicators of abuse. 

Indicators of child abuse include situations where the child:

  • Has bruises, broken bones, burns, or black eyes that they cannot explain
  • Has injuries that are healing after they have missed school or child care
  • Seem unwilling to go home or is afraid of parents/caretakers
  • Recoils at the touch of a parent/caretaker
  • Reports a suspicious injury/scenario

A parent or caretaker can also display indicators of abuse.  These include:

  • Offering unconvincing or conflicting explanations for a child’s injuries
  • Describing the child in overly negative terms
  • Disciplining the child in a harsh manner
  • Having a history of abuse

Signs of Sexual Abuse:

Sexual abuse is difficult because in some situations, such as fondling, there is no physical evidence.  In these situations, it is even more important that adults in the child’s life, especially mandated reporters, look for a child’s behavioral changes.  The child’s testimony is one of the most important factors in these cases because childhood sexual abuse is conducted in private.

Children may display the following signs if they were the victim of sexual abuse:

  • Sudden refusal to participate in physical activity
  • Difficulty walking or sitting
  • Demonstrates unusual or sophisticated sexual behavior or knowledge
  • Sudden change in appetite
  • Contracts an STD
  • Becomes pregnant
  • Runs away from home
  • Reports sexual abuse

Parents or adult caregivers who are sexual perpetrators may exhibit the following signs:

  • Unusually protective of the child
  • Limit the child’s interaction with other people
  • Jealous or controlling with family members
  • Secretive and isolated

Signs of Neglect:

For children, signs of neglect include:

  • Recurrent school absences
  • Appearance is dirty or has severe body odor
  • Lacks necessary medical or dental care
  • Begs/ steals money for food
  • Lack of appropriate clothing
  • Abuses drugs and alcohol
  • Reports that they are not receiving adequate care

Signs that a parent or caregiver may be neglecting a child include:

  • Indifference to the child
  • Is apathetic/depressed
  • Irrational behavior
  • Alcohol or drug abuse

Signs of Emotional Abuse:

It is difficult to determine if a child is being emotionally abused, but you can look for the following sings:

  • Extremes in behavior (overly demanding, aggressive, compliant, or passive)
  • Overly mature or overly childish
  • Delays in physical/emotional development
  • Has attempted suicide
  • Reports a lack of attachment to parent/caretaker

Signs that a parent/caretaker is emotionally abusive:

  • Overly cold and unconcerned about child
  • Belittles / berates / blames child consistently
  • Openly rejects the child

Impact of Child Abuse

Child abuse / neglect can have serious and long-lasting impacts on the child’s physical, mental, and behavioral well-being.  The effects depend on the circumstances of the abuse/neglect including: the child’s age, type of abuse, frequency/duration/severity of abuse, and relationship of perpetrator and child.  The type of treatment that the child receives after the abuse/neglect can also have a serious impact. 

There are direct and indirect social costs associated with child abuse and neglect.  These costs include costs associated with child welfare, investigations, and costs associated with subsequent criminal activity, substance abuse, domestic violence, and mental illness. 

Physical health consequences of abuse/neglect are injuries (bruises, cuts, broken bones, brain injuries, death, recurring health complications, and poor development.  Behavioral consequences include teen delinquency and pregnancy, poor academic performance, drug use, alcohol and drug abuse, and subsequent abusive behavior.  Mental consequences include emotional effects, low self-esteem, depression, withdrawal, cognitive difficulties, and social problems.

When choosing a child care facility, it is important to make a list of priority features and thoroughly investigate prospective facilities.  And, almost as important is to keep up with your child’s care, visiting the facility and keeping an open dialogue with the caretakers. 

As a parent, you want to surround your child with a network of adults who have your child’s best interest in mind.  Public awareness, education, and prevention are the best tools in preventing child abuse and neglect.  If your child has suffered injury, abuse, or even death, while under the care of a caretaker, you may be entitled to compensation and at the least, hold that person responsible.

Sources:

ChildCare.gov

Child Welfare Information Gateway

U.S. Department of Health and Human Services: Administration for Children & Families

DHHS: Child Care Development Fund (CCDF)

DHHS: Temporary Assistance for Needy Families (TANF)

DHHS: Child Welfare Information Gateway

Injury Prevention Policy: Child Care Safety

National Resource Center for Health and Safety in Child Care and Early Education
National Association of Child Care Resources & Referral Agencies

About.com: Child Care
Illinois Department of Children and Family Services: Day Care & Early Childhood

Illinois Early Learning Project: How Do I Start a Child Care Center in Illinois?

Illinois State Requirements: Daycare

Child Care Aware

National Child Care Information and Technical Assistance Center (NCCIC): Child care options

Nursing Home Abuse Blog: Trust Your Instinct When Placing a Child in Daycare with Potential Hazards

Nursing Home Abuse Blog: Children in Day Care Are Susceptible to Many of the Same Problems Our Elderly Nursing Home Patients Encounter

American Academy of Pediatrics: Caring for Our Children: National Health and Safety Performance Standards: Guidelines for Out-of-Home Child Care Programs, 2nd edition

Rosenfeld Injury Lawyers: Day Care Injuries

Understanding The Regulations Pertaining To Day Care Facilities Is Crucial To Protecting Your Child

girlwithsun.jpgDay Care Centers are facilities that provide child care for less than 24 hours/day for over eight children if it is a family home or over three children in a non-home facility. 

In Illinois, these Centers are regulated by the Part 407 (Licensing Standards for Day Care Centers) of the Illinois Administrative Code.  DCFS inspects and licensees these facilities (license valid for three years). 

Day Care Centers must meet certain health and safety guidelines including but not limited to: ensuring that all children are supervised at all times, emergency drills, first aid kit, sanitary and hazard free conditions, hazardous substances kept out of reach.  In addition, depending on the time of day and length of stay, the facility must provide nutritious food and snacks. 

Day care centers require a director (at least 21 years old with 2 years of college or experience and 15 hours of training/year), and each caregiver must have a medical report as well as a background check.  The children to staff ratios can be found in the following table:

 

Age of Children

Provider to Child Ratio for Child Care Centers in Illinois

Maximum Group Size

Infants

1:4

12

Toddlers

1:5

15

2 Years

1:8

16

3 Years

1:10

20

4 Years

1:10

20

Preschool (5 years)

1:20

20

School Age (kindergarteners present

1:20

30

Mixed Age Group

Ratio for youngest child in group

30

Day Care Homes

Day Care Homes are homes that provide care for more than three, but less than twelve children for less than 24 hours a day.  These homes are regulated by Part 406 (Licensing Standards for Day Care Homes) of Illinois’ Administrative Code.  It lists licensing standards and how to apply.  As part of the licensing process, DCFS has to inspect the facility to ensure that it meets requirements.  The license is valid for three years. 

The facility/home must meet safety guidelines including but not limited to: fire extinguisher and smoke detector, first aid kit, no chipping paint or lead paint, hazardous materials kept out of reach, child proofing, and clean and sanitary conditions.  The facility must also provide adequate daily nutrition, which varies depending on the time of day and length of stay. 

The caregiver of a day care home must be at least 18 years of age and must complete fifteen hours of training/year.  They must also provide proof that they are free of transmissible diseases and undergo a background check.  The children to staff ratios for group homes are:

  • ≤ eight children under 12 years of age, where only six can be under 5 years of age, and only two can be younger than 30 months, or
  • ≤ eight children under 12 years of age, where only five can be under 5 years of age, and only three can be younger than 24 months, or
  • Eight school-aged children
  • A part-time assistant can provide care for four additional school-aged children
  • If there is a full-time assistant, they can care for ≤ eight children under 5 years old where only five can be younger than 24 month

Group Day Care Homes

Group Day Care Homes provide care for 3-16 children for less than 24 hours/day.  These Homes are regulated by Part 408 (Licensing Standards for Group Day Care Homes) of Illinois Administrative Code.  The Code includes licensing requirements (license valid for three years, inspected yearly by DCFS).   

These homes must meet health and safety guidelines including; emergency supplies (first aid kit, flashlight), child proofing, smoke detectors, working phones, and a clean and safe environment.  There are also guidelines about night care; these guidelines cover bathing, beds and sleeping arrangements, and food. 

Caregivers at group day care homes must be at least 21 years old, full-time assistants must be at least 18 years old, and part-time assistants must be at least 14 years old.  Caregivers are required to undergo background checks.  The caregiver must have one year of college credit or equivalent work experience, and must undergo 15 years of training every year. 

A day care home cannot provide care for more than 16 children.  Children to staff ratios are as follows:

1 caregiver (alone) may provide care for:

  • ≤ eight children under 12 years old, where only six can be under 5 years old and only two younger than 30 months, or
  • ≤ eight children under 12 years old, where only five can be under 5 years old and only three can be younger than 24 months, or
  • ≤ eight pre-school aged children, where none are younger than 3 years old, or 
  • ≤ twelve school age children.

1 caregiver + one assistant (at least 18 years of age) may care for:

  • ≤ twelve children 3-6 years old, or
  • ≤ twelve children under 6 years old, where only six can be younger than 30 months and only four can be younger than 15 months

1 caregiver + 1 part-time assistant may care for:

  • Four more children before or after school

Abuse/Neglect In Child Care Facilities

Unfortunately, child abuse and neglect does occur at child care facilities.  In some situations, there are merely too many children for the caregivers to safely monitor, which leads to unsafe conditions and neglect.  In other situations, intentional abuse can occur.  That is why it is so important that facilities conduct criminal background checks on all employees and monitors its employees. 

The Federal Child Abuse Prevention and Treatment Act (CAPTA) defines child abuse and neglect as:

  • An act or failure to act by a parent or caregiver that results in death, serious injury (physical or emotional), sexual abuse, or exploitation, or
  • An act or failure to act that creates a situation of imminent danger

States are left with the task of providing more specific definitions for child abuse and neglect.  Most states include definitions in regulatory code (mandatory child abuse reporting statutes (criminal and civil), criminal statutes, and juvenile court statutes).  In Illinois, these definitions are found in Child Protection, 325 ILCS 2, 5,15 and  Child Welfare 20 ILCS 505, 520; 705 ILCS 405

Illinois’ licensing requirements specifies what type of behavior and actions are not allowed at day care homes, day care centers, and group day care homes.  Prohibited behavior includes, but is not limited to:

  • Corporal punishment
  • Humiliation or making derogatory comments about a child’s family
  • Abusive or profane language
  • Emotional abuse
  • Punishment for toilet accidents
  • Depriving or threatening to deprive a child of a meal
  • Time-out that exceeds the time in minutes of a child’s age in years

Physical Abuse (325 ILCS 5/3)

The ANCRA (Abused and Neglected Child Reporting Act) includes a definition of physical abuse.  The definition includes situations where a parent or caretaker inflicts or causes to be inflicted death, disfigurement, or impairment, creates a high risk of physical injury, tortures, or inflicts excessive bodily punishment. 

If a parent/caretaker does not take reasonable steps to stop sexual abuse/physical abuse/exploitation (325 ILCS 5/3), then they can also be charged with abuse.  Sexual abuse is the sexual penetration of the child (including vaginal, oral, and anal sex).  Sexual exploitation is defined by DCFS as the “sexual use of a child for sexual arousal, gratification, advantage, or profit” (includes child porn, verbal enticements, masturbating to a child’s presence, or forcing a child to watch sexual acts).  Sexual molestation is “sexual conduct with a child when such contact, touching, or interaction is used for arousal or gratification of sexual needs or desires” (fondling a child, having a child touch the perpetrator in a sexual manner). 

Neglect (325 ILCS 5/3) occurs when a parent or caretaker fails to provide or denies a child of adequate food, clothes, shelter, or medical treatment, or leaves a child unsupervised or under the care of a person who is unable to supervise. 

In situations where you are unsure whether or not abuse/neglect has occurred, ask yourself whether the child has been harmed or is at risk of harm.  The laws and regulations are in place to protect a child’s safety and well-being. 

Rosenfeld Injury Lawyers, utilizes all applicable laws to assist in the prosecution of cases involving abuse and injury at day care facilities.  Put our experience to work for you today. As always, our personal injury consultations are free and completely confidential.

Special thanks to Heather Keil, J.D. for her work on this Child Injury Laws Blog entry.

Watchdog Group Confirms Trouble At Chicago Nursing Home Caring For Disabled Children

 

A federal watchdog group has confirmed widely published news reports of unnecessary death at a well known Chicago nursing home that caters to disabled children and young adults.  After conducting its own investigation of care at the facility, Equip for Equality has confirmed at least five more deaths at Alden Village North were related to poor care and slopping medical care.

According to a recent article from Wgntv.com, basic protocols such as: improper diagnoses, delayed physician responses to staff inquiries and ignored lab results were to blame at least eight deaths at the Chicago institution since 2008.

These investigative results come on the heels of earlier reports regarding the recent deaths of young people at the facility due to similar errors.

Not surprisingly, a spokesman for Alden disputes the findings;

While we respect the work of Equip for Equality, we strongly disagree with their conclusions in this report.  The reality is that since taking over this facility in 2008, we have invested tremendous resources in improvements to the environment and the staff.  Our residents are like family to us and we mourn whenever one of them passes.  The individuals discussed in this report died as a result of the complex and serious medical conditions they faced.  The care that we provided sustained their lives.

Certainly, in the wake of these recent deaths, I hope that this Alden facility is conducting a far more intensive internal audit of their practices than their spokesperson appears to portray.  Given the number of suspicious deaths at this facility, I would certainly hope that state regulators similarly look at this facility with more scrutiny to ensure the safety of these young people.

Related:

Nursing Home Abuse: The Deaths Of 13 Children Linked To Poor Care At Chicago Nursing Home

Children In Nursing Homes: Truly The Most Vulnerable

Alden Village North Charged With Neglect After Child Dies Due To Inadequate Nursing Care

Illinois Nursing Homes With Second Quarter 2010 Violations

Daycare Owner Faces Murder Charges Following Death Of Infant

As a lawyer who frequently sees children injured in a day care setting, I am frustrated by how many of the situations that give rise to a child's injury get brushed away and forgotten because their is inadequate evidence to support a criminal charge against the caregiver. 

Christina LyonsIn this sense, I was actually glad to see prosecutors exercising some muscle when it came to criminally charging a daycare owner where an infant recently died under her care from traumatic injuries.  Despite conflicting stories, the daycare owner, Christina Suzanne Lyons, will be charged with injury to a child and capital murder. 

The charges stem from a November incident that left a 10-week-old boy with traumatic injuries to his head and ribs.  Despite extensive medical treatments, the little boy died soon after the incident.

The incident itself is at issue with differing versions of how the injuries occurred.  According to Ms. Lyon's original police statement, the boy sustained injuries when she left him unattended on a couch when she went to smoke a cigarette and use the toilet.  Ms. Lyon's alleges that the boy may have sustained his injuries when her four-year-old daughter attended to him.

Ms. Lyon's explanation seemed unlikely to the grand jury that handed down her indictment.  An affidavit from first responders claims that the the boy was unresponsive and required assisted breathing when police arrived.  A police report noted that the infant sustained "multiple bilateral posterior rib fractures" and required surgery due to "severe head trauma".  Further, a police officer said that the severity of the boys injuries were unlikely inflicted by a child.

Ms. Lyons remains in police custody as she awaits her trial.  Read more about this day care tragedy here.

As demonstrated by this situation, a timely investigation into an incident at a daycare facility can frequently provide parents with valuable information as to how their child was injured.  Particularly, in light of the fact that a daycare employee may attempt to hide what actually happened, I always suggest parents contact their local police department as soon as feasible so a fair and unbiased assessment of the circumstances can be conducted.

Related:

Toddler Receives Burns In Daycare Due To Caregiver's Poor Judgment

Almost A Year Later.... Confusion Still Surrounds Death Of Child In Chicagoland Day Care Center

Take Some Time To Fully Evaluate Your Child Care Options Before Selecting A Facility

Trust Your Instinct When Placing A Child In Daycare With Potential Hazards

Almost A Year Later.... Confusion Still Surrounds Death Of Child In Chicagoland Day Care Center

A suburban Chicago judge will soon determine how many—if any of the statements made by day care worker, Melissa Calusinki, during a video-recorded police interrogation will be admissible at her upcoming criminal trial.

Calusinki is charged with first-degree murder following the death of a toddler, Benjamin Kingan, at Minee Subee in the Park day care center in 2009.  Conflicting statements made during the four-hour interrogation by both Calusinki and the police enforcement officials interrogating her provide little clarity as how the toddler’s fatal head injury occurred.

During some portions of the interrogation, Calusinki claims that the boy’s injury resulted from him throwing himself on the ground, yet in other portions it appears as though Calusinki played more of an active role--- and actually threw the boy to the ground.

As Ms. Calusinki awaits trial, she remains in custody of law enforcement authorities, as she was unable to satisfy the $5 million bond a judge earlier imposed.

In addition to the criminal charges brought against both Calusinki as well as the owner of the day care center, the facility remains closed as ordered by state authorities.

As a lawyer who represents families following injuries to children while at a day care centers, I frequently find myself frustrated by conflicting reports of events.  Consequently, I strongly urge families to seek the involvement of law enforcement officials as well as officials from the state who are responsible for regulating these facilities.

While not always the case, the investigative reports from these agencies responsible for regulating day care facilities can be extremely helpful in both providing answers to the family as to how the incident may have occurred as well as valuable in the prosecution of personal injuries in a civil court setting.

Related:

Interrogation recording shaping case in day care center death, by Ruth Fuller, Chicago Tribune, December 8, 2010

Family Settles Day Care Death Lawsuit NBC5.com, March 7, 2010

Day-care center is open after boy's death Chicago Breaking News Center, January 19, 2009

Rosenfeld Injury Lawyers: Day Care Injuries

Toddler Receives Burns In Daycare Due To Caregiver's Poor Judgment

Scald burns

A two-year old toddler is spending time in the burn unit of an Indiana hospital after the caregiver at his daycare center tried to apparently teach him a cruel lesson for poorly aiming while urinating.

After an initial claim that the boy simply 'fell' into a tub of lukewarm water, the caregiver acknowledged that the boy received scald burns when she deliberately placed him in boiling hot water at her home-based daycare center.

Now the caregiver and daycare owner, identified as Irene Martin, faces criminal charges of felony neglect and battery.  If convicted, Ms. Martin would spend at least 12-and-a-half years in jail.

Childhood burns

The toddler in this case sustained second degree burns to his legs, back and penis.  Part of the necessary medical treatment will likely include a procedure known as skin graft where healthy skin is harvested by surgeons and transferred to an burned area.

My heart goes out to this boy, who faces a painful recovery from this needless injury.  Sadly, scald burn injuries (caused by hot liquids or steam) is the most common type of burn-related injury amongst children.

Young childrens' developing skin makes them especially susceptible to severe burns from liquids that may be harmless to adults.  For example, if a young child is exposed to hot tap water at 140 degrees F-- for just three seconds-- he or she can sustain a third-degree burn.

Infants and toddlers are perhaps most vulnerable to scald-related burns because they lack the ability to appreciate the danger.  Parents and caregivers should take extra precautions to prevent burns of young children.  Common burn prevention includes:

  • Never leaving kids unattended in a shower or bath-- when they can modify the water temperature
  • Reduce the temperature on water-heaters
  • Never boil water in pot at the front of the stove
  • Don't microwave liquids

Related:

Daycare owner charged with scalding toddler Fox19.com October 24, 2010

Preventing Uniintentional Scald Burns- Moving Beyond Tap Water (PDF) Pediatrics 2008;122;799-804, Gina Lowell, Kyran Quinlan and Lawrence J. Gottlieb

BURN INJURY (PDF)

Kids Health: Burns

Nursing Homes Abuse Blog: Burns In The Nursing Home Population Pose A Serious Threat Of Injury & Further Medical Complications

About Jonathan Rosenfeld

Photo of Jonathan Rosenfeld

About Jonathan Rosenfeld My law practice is focused on representing the most vulnerable members of our society in claims and lawsuits...

Read More

Subscribe

Add this blog to your feeds or subscribe by email using the form below

Begin the process of learning the legal options available for your child today.

Bed Sore FAQs

Frequently asked questions on bed sore prevention, treatment and legal rights of those who have been neglected.

View FAQs
Nursing Home Laws - View Laws by State